Tumble Creek Homes For Sale - The Current Tumble Creek Real Estate Market

-written by Courtney Neese 2/24/2025 

Are you interested in mountain homes and looking for a Tumble Creek home for sale? There are some great choices right now.  I would love to tell you about my favorites and also which parts of Tumble Creek are better for you depending on why you are interested in the area.  Tumble Creek is Suncadia’s more exclusive section and it has a culture that is all its own.  While still enjoying the amenities of Suncadia, as a Tumble Creek home owner you have access to an even greater amount of amenities that are private to only Tumble Creek Club residents.  You can read some more about the basics of Tumble Creek here:  Tumble Creek Buyer’s Guide

So let’s look at the Tumble Creek real estate market right now. 

Currently there are 22 Tumble Creek homes for sale in the MLS ranging in price from $1,789,000 to $6,950,000 with an average days on market of 184 ranging from 11 to 451days and an average dollar per square foot of $685.18 with a range of $551.52 to $1037.60 a square foot.  The current median list price for these homes in Tumble Creek is $2,345,000. 

What Tumble Creek homes have "moved"  lately?

An uptick of buyers looking at Suncadia and Tumble Creek for that perfect weekend get away or full time residence has been evident. Five Tumble Creek homes for sale are under contract and currently either pending, pending inspection, or contingent in the MLS. They range in list price from $1,579,900 to $2,998,000 with an average days on market of 138  and an average dollar per square foot of $688.01.  The median list price for these pending Tumble Creek homes for sale is $2,088.598.

How about SOLD Tumble Creek homes? 

Just one Tumble Creek home for sale in the MLS  has closed in escrow this year so far.  It was a new construction home at 1130 Domerie Park Lp.and one of the great places in the Mountain Home Collection by Landed Gentry. This Tumble Creek new construction home was listed for $1,399,900 and sold for $1,442,082 (103.01% over list) in 3 days with a dollar per square foot of $636.12. For those of you that are new to looking at homes in Tumble Creek, one home sold in 2025 so far  is not an alarm bell. For anyone paying attention and educated on the stats of the market this does not mean that “Tumble Creek homes are not selling”. It is typical this early in the year for there only to be one to two sales in the same time period.  Last year there were none in the same time frame so one is exactly on course for the norm. In fact last year 22 Tumble Creek homes sold in the MLS for the entire year with the first sale occurring in March.

Final words for thought... 

Would you like to look at Tumble Creek or Suncadia homes for sale? As a broker, my 25+ years of experience and knowledge is a handy tool to have by your side should you decide to buy or sell in Tumble Creek or Suncadia. Knowing that Tumble Creek homes are in fact selling at the typical rate for the community is one example of hyper knowledge versus a less experienced broker who may tell you that Tumble Creek homes are not selling because they may see one home sale.  It’s a unique market and it’s important to have an advocate who can see the entire market and knows the stats and trends. Please feel free to reach out and let’s talk about what you are looking for.